Posted in Personal Injury
Many injury cases settle, and in Wisconsin the way a settlement offer is made can affect who pays costs and interest if the case goes to trial. A formal offer is not the same as a conversation with an adjuster. The rules are in the court procedure statutes, and they apply to both sides.
What Is a Statutory Offer of Settlement?
Under Wisconsin Statutes section 807.01, a party can serve a written offer of settlement after the issue is joined and at least 20 days before trial. A defendant may offer to allow judgment for a stated sum with costs. A plaintiff may offer to settle for a stated sum with costs. Each has a different consequence if the offer is rejected.
How Long Does the Other Side Have to Respond?
The receiving party has 10 days to accept, and the acceptance must be in writing. If no written acceptance is served, the offer can’t be used as evidence at trial and can’t be mentioned there. A rejected offer stays out of the jury’s sight, but it still affects costs and interest after the verdict.
Ten days goes quickly. An offer that arrives just before a holiday or a medical procedure still counts from receipt.
What Happens to Costs if an Offer Is Rejected?
The statute allocates costs based on how the judgment compares to the offer:
- If a defendant’s offer is rejected and the plaintiff doesn’t obtain a more favorable judgment, the plaintiff doesn’t recover costs, and the defendant recovers costs.
- If a plaintiff’s offer is rejected and the plaintiff obtains a more favorable judgment, the plaintiff recovers double the taxable costs.
Those consequences encourage each side to take the other’s offer seriously.
How Does Interest Come Into It?
A party whose unaccepted offer is matched or beaten by the judgment is entitled to simple interest from the offer date until payment. The rate is 1 percent plus the prime rate, using the rate on January 1 for judgments entered by June 30 and the rate on July 1 for later judgments. This interest takes the place of the interest that would otherwise apply.
For a plaintiff, an offer that the judgment later matches or beats can add interest to the recovery. Whether to serve one depends on the evidence, and that is a decision worth making with a Menomonee Falls personal injury lawyer who knows the case.
How Should an Injured Person Weigh an Offer?
An offer is only as good as the information behind it. Before deciding, an injured person should know the full amount of medical bills, future treatment needs, lost income, and the long-term effect on daily life. Cases can settle for less than their real value when those numbers are incomplete. Knowing the average car accident settlement is a starting point, but each case depends on its own facts.
Cases don’t always need a courtroom to resolve. Choosing between settling out of court and going to trial is a decision that rests on the evidence and on the risks of each path.
Where Do Offers Show Up in Different Cases?
Formal offers arise in any injury lawsuit. After a crash, an offer gets weighed against vehicle data and medical records, which is work a Menomonee Falls car accident lawyer does.
After a fall, the same offer is measured against proof of what the property owner knew. Gathering that proof, such as maintenance records and photographs of the hazard, is work a Menomonee Falls slip and fall lawyer does.
How Do We Approach Settlement Offers?
At Hickey & Turim, S.C., we represent injured people, and attorney David Turim has practiced in Wisconsin since 1985. We review any offer against the documented damages and the strength of the liability evidence before advising on a response. Offers that arrive with a short deadline get priority.
Why Does the Timing of an Offer Matter?
The 10-day window, the cost consequences, and the interest rate all depend on dates, so each offer should be tracked from the day it arrives. Anyone with a pending injury lawsuit in Menomonee Falls who has received or is considering a formal offer can reach out to a Menomonee Falls personal injury lawyer before the response deadline passes.